What Is a Win Worth in Youth Basketball?

Too many youth basketball programs are willing to skip steps for a win. They’ll play kids down in age or enter a league they already know they can run through. The record looks great. Then those players walk into a gym where everybody is just as big and just as fast. Can they guard somebody? Can they make a play when their first option is gone?

I care about those questions all the way through high school. By the time a player walks into a university gym, I want them to have years of reps making those decisions under pressure. Development is hard. It gets messy. A kid can make the right read in practice on Tuesday and miss it three times on Saturday. You come back to practice and keep teaching it.

Teach defence that holds up

You can sit in a zone against 11-year-olds and dare them to shoot from outside or throw a pass over the top. Plenty of kids that age are still building the strength and skill to do either consistently. Teach man-to-man and every player has to learn to guard the ball, talk through screens, help on a drive and recover. Early on, help will be late and players will give up layups. Over time, they learn to see the drive coming and rotate before it gets to the rim.

Give players decisions on offence

A good system gives players rules for spacing, cutting and moving the ball, and room to make their own decisions. If your defender jumps the passing lane, cut backdoor. If the help defender steps up on your drive, find the teammate they left open. The play calls will change at the next level. The reads will still be there, and players will have less time to make them.

Work on what players struggle with

A big kid can score over smaller players for an entire season and barely handle the ball outside the paint. Give that player reps dribbling out of pressure and passing on the move. If a guard always goes right, get them finishing left against a live defender. Then give both players a chance to use those skills in games, even when their first few attempts look rough.

Hold players accountable and stay in their corner

Hold your leading scorer accountable when they jog back after a turnover. When a kid is having a rough stretch, be honest about what needs to get better and put in the time to help them fix it. Sometimes being in a player’s corner means pulling them aside, giving them one clear job and trusting them with the next possession.

Build a plan for every age group

A program should know what each age group is responsible for teaching and what the next coach will build on. With younger teams, that means footwork, spacing and guarding the ball. By high school, those same fundamentals show up in ball-screen coverages, reads against pressure and late-game execution. When coaches use the same system and language year after year, players can build on what they learned last season as the decisions get harder.

Compete to win every day

We try to win the warm-up. I want our guys sharper and more ready to play than the team at the other end. We compete in every drill at practice. We want to win every game. Our players and coaches bust their butts for it.

We play our stronger teams up an age group when they’re ready. That means bigger, faster opponents, more close games and more losses. It also means our guys get to make decisions with the game on the line. Down two with 30 seconds left, can we get a good shot? Up one, can we talk through a ball screen and finish the stop with a rebound?

I’ll take those reps over a 50-point win every time.

A note for parents

Before you commit to a spot for your son or daughter, ask what they’ll learn this season and how the program will build on it next year. Who will coach them every week? How does the program decide what level they’ll play at? How does the coach help a player through a rough stretch?

If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is. Do your homework on the people who’ll be leading your child. Watch a practice if you can, and talk to families who’ve been there for a few seasons. Find a basketball home where your child can grow for years with coaches you trust.

Dustin Mactaggart Basketball

Meet Dustin Mactaggart. His journey began as a key player at Parkside High School, where he helped secure the OFSAA Championship during his junior year. He continued his basketball and academic pursuits at Fanshawe College in London, Ontario.

Dustin transitioned into coaching in 2018 at Oakville Prep, quickly rising from lead assistant to head coach. Over three years, he shaped athletes' skills and character, establishing himself as a respected leader. His coaching path then led to Prolific Prep in Napa, California, where he contributed to the Grind Session Championship and a significant run at the Geico Nationals. Simultaneously, he head coached Napa Christian Knights, steering them to the Northern California state sectional final and state championship semi-finals.

In addition to coaching, Dustin founded Let It Fly Basketball Training, developing players at NBA, NCAA D1, U Sports, and high school levels. He further expanded his impact with LIFT Basketball, a player-focused rep and AAU program based in Burlington. His work includes contributing to Canada Basketball's national skill development initiatives.

Dustin also shares his knowledge as a writer for The Maple Minute, one of Canada’s premier high school basketball scouting services, showcasing his eye for talent and passion for the sport.

Dustin lives in Burlington with his fiancée, Maya, and their baby, JJ, continuing his mission to inspire and uplift athletes at all levels of the game.

Next
Next

Why the 3-Point Shot and Analytics Matter for Today’s Players